Solving Linear and Nonlinear Problems in Excel

Excel’s Solver tool can be used to solve both linear and nonlinear optimization problems. Linear problems involve a linear relationship between variables, while nonlinear problems involve non-linear relationships. In this tutorial, you will learn how to use Solver to solve both types of problems with real-time examples.

Step-by-Step Tutorial

Step 1: Install Solver Add-in

If Solver is not already installed in your Excel, follow these steps:

  1. Click on the "File" tab.
  2. Select "Options" to open the Excel Options dialog box.
  3. In the dialog box, select "Add-ins".
  4. At the bottom, next to "Manage", select "Excel Add-ins" and click "Go".
  5. Check the "Solver Add-in" box and click "OK".

Step 2: Set Up the Data

Before using Solver, you need to have a model or a set of equations to solve. Let’s go through a linear and a nonlinear example for better understanding.

Linear Problem Example

In this example, we will solve a linear problem to maximize profit given constraints. Assume you run a company that manufactures two products, A and B. Each product generates a profit, and we want to maximize the total profit subject to certain limitations (e.g., production capacity).

Example Setup:

        Product A Profit: $40 (in cell A2)
        Product B Profit: $50 (in cell A3)
        Product A Units: 100 (in cell B2) 
        Product B Units: 100 (in cell B3) 
        Total Profit: =A2*B2 + A3*B3 (in cell B4)

Let’s assume the following constraints:

  • The production of Product A is limited to 500 units.
  • The production of Product B is limited to 300 units.
  • The total labor hours available for production are 1000 hours, with each unit of Product A taking 2 hours and each unit of Product B taking 3 hours.

Step-by-step to Set Up Solver for Linear Problem:

  1. In cell A2, enter the profit for Product A: 40.
  2. In cell A3, enter the profit for Product B: 50.
  3. In cell B2, enter the initial units for Product A: 100.
  4. In cell B3, enter the initial units for Product B: 100.
  5. In cell B4, enter the total profit formula: =A2*B2 + A3*B3.
  6. In cell B5, enter the total labor usage formula: =2*B2 + 3*B3.

Using Solver:

  1. Click on the "Data" tab and then click "Solver" in the "Analysis" group.
  2. Set the "Set Objective" field to B4 (Total Profit) and select "Max" to maximize the profit.
  3. Set the "By Changing Variable Cells" field to B2 and B3 (units of Product A and Product B).
  4. Add the following constraints:
    • Product A units: B2 <= 500 (production limit).
    • Product B units: B3 <= 300 (production limit).
    • Total labor usage: B5 <= 1000 (labor hours limit).
  5. Click "Solve" to find the optimal solution.

Solver will calculate the optimal number of units for Product A and Product B to maximize profit while staying within the given constraints (production limits and labor hours).

Nonlinear Problem Example

Nonlinear optimization problems involve a nonlinear relationship between the decision variables. A typical example is maximizing profit subject to nonlinear constraints, such as the cost per unit increasing as the number of units produced grows.

Example Setup:

        Product A Profit: $40 (in cell A2)
        Product B Profit: $50 (in cell A3)
        Product A Units: 100 (in cell B2)
        Product B Units: 100 (in cell B3)
        Total Profit: =A2*B2 + A3*B3 (in cell B4)

Let’s assume the cost per unit increases as follows:

  • Cost of Product A: $10 per unit initially, but increases by $0.1 per unit for each additional unit produced.
  • Cost of Product B: $15 per unit initially, but increases by $0.2 per unit for each additional unit produced.

We want to maximize the profit while considering the nonlinear cost increase.

Step-by-step to Set Up Solver for Nonlinear Problem:

  1. In cell A2, enter the profit for Product A: 40.
  2. In cell A3, enter the profit for Product B: 50.
  3. In cell B2, enter the initial units for Product A: 100.
  4. In cell B3, enter the initial units for Product B: 100.
  5. In cell B4, enter the total profit formula: =A2*B2 + A3*B3.
  6. In cell C2, enter the formula for Product A cost: =10 + 0.1*B2.
  7. In cell C3, enter the formula for Product B cost: =15 + 0.2*B3.
  8. In cell B5, calculate the total cost: =C2*B2 + C3*B3.

Using Solver for Nonlinear Problem:

  1. Click on "Data" and select "Solver."
  2. Set the "Set Objective" to B4 (Total Profit) and select "Max" to maximize the profit.
  3. Set the "By Changing Variable Cells" to B2 and B3 (units of Product A and Product B).
  4. Add the following constraints:
    • Cost for Product A: C2 <= 20 (maximum cost per unit).
    • Cost for Product B: C3 <= 25 (maximum cost per unit).
  5. Click "Solve" to find the optimal number of units for each product.

Solver will calculate the optimal values for Product A and Product B to maximize profit, considering the nonlinear cost constraints. The problem here involves non-linear cost functions, and Solver will handle it accordingly.

Tips for Solving Linear and Nonlinear Problems

  • For linear problems, ensure that the relationships between variables are linear (e.g., straight-line relationships).
  • For nonlinear problems, be aware that Solver may take longer to find a solution, especially for complex nonlinear equations.
  • Use Solver's "Options" to adjust the algorithm settings if Solver is not converging on a solution.
  • Ensure that constraints are realistic and do not conflict with the objective function.

Conclusion

Solver in Excel is a powerful tool for solving both linear and nonlinear optimization problems. By following the steps above and applying it to real-time examples, you can easily optimize your business models, financial planning, or production schedules. Whether your problem involves linear relationships or complex nonlinear constraints, Solver can help you find the best solution.




Advertisement